Consignment Made Easy
We take the hassle out of selling used surfboards. Drop your board off, we handle the rest—photos, cleaning, listings, buyers, and sales. More exposure, less stress, and faster sales.
Drop off your board
We'll go over your board with you making sure it's in good condition and help you set the best price.
We handle the rest
Let us handle all the dirty work from cleaning and small ding repairs. We make sure every board is water tight and ready to ride.
Post to our website
We maintain a well organized easy to navigate platform allowing your board to be found by the right customer.
Facebook Market
We also post to FB market getting maximum exposure while handling all questions and correspondences with buyers.
You Get Paid!
After we successfully sell your board we'll send you your cash directly to your bank account.
Not into waiting? Ask us about:
Buyouts – Depending on the type and condition you can ask us to make you an offer and take the board off your hands right away.
Store Credit Trade-Ins – Depending on the type and condition you can ask us to trade your old board in for shop credit and put it toward your next stick today.
Boards We are Stoked to Take
Shortboards, Longboards (up to 11ft), Fish, Funboards, Midlengths, Step-ups, Mini Guns and Guns (from Sep - Feb), Soft Tops...
Fins must be removable and of the most current systems (FCS, FCS II, Futures, and standard skeg boxes)
No need to remove the wax, stickers or dirt, we do all that for you.
Minor open dings are ok, we can seals those up for you.
Large open dings and fin box compromises will be repaired by us prior to listing and the cost can be taken out of your share when sold
Boards We Can't Take
Surfboards longer than 11 feet
Surfboards with glassed on fins. The fins must be removable
Surfboards with excessive delamination
Surfboards with excessive sun damage and brittle fiberglass
Waterlogged surfboards
Buckled or snapped boards
Stand Up Paddle (SUP) Boards. Sorry limited space
Hydrofoils Sorry limited space
Surfboards with discontinued fin box systems
Consignment Agreement
At Sand Island Surf Shop, our goal is to make selling your surfboard simple, fair, and hassle-free.
Pricing & Fees
We price boards at current market value to help them sell fast and for a fair return. A 30% service fee is charged on the sale price.
We don’t mark up boards based on what you’d like to get out of it—our pricing is based on what boards are actually selling for.
Markdown Schedule
To keep boards moving and maintain fresh inventory, we follow a set markdown schedule:
After 30 days, price drops by 10%.
After 60 days, an additional 10% reduction.
After 180 days, we may relist the board with another 10% markdown and restart the 60-day cycle.
After one year, boards may be included in our $99 and under semiannual sale.
Cleaning & Repairs
We clean every board before display—removing stickers, mounts, and worn stomp pads.
Minor dings are sealed with solar resin.
For more serious repairs, we’ll contact you first. If you approve, the repair cost will be deducted from your portion of the sale.
Posting & Marketing
We aim to list all boards on our website and Facebook Marketplace within one week, though some boards may take a little longer depending on condition and season.
Early Pickup Fee
If you choose to pick up your board within the first 30 days, a $50 service/processing fee applies to cover cleaning, listing, and promotion costs.
Offers & Communication
We do not contact consignors with individual offers. Boards sell according to the agreed pricing and markdown schedule—this keeps the process smooth and fair for everyone.
Payment
Once your board sells, your payout will be sent via ACH or PayPal, based on your preference.
All payments are processed every Monday:
ACH: 3–5 business days to arrive in your account.
PayPal: Funds are released after one week and available immediately once sent.